| Year | Sport | Student-Athlete |
| 1976 | Men’s Track & Field | Robert Anding |
| 1979 | Football | Robert Dugas |
| 1983 | Football | James Britt |
| 1988 | Football | Ignazio Albergamo |
| 1989 | Men’s Track & Field | Mikael Olander |
| 1990 | Men’s Track & Field | Bengt Arne Jarlsjo |
| 1991 | Football | Sol Graves |
| 1992 | Men’s Basketball | Justin Anderson |
| 1994 | Football | Chad Loup |
| 1994 | Women’s Basketball | Miriam Farr |
| 1996 | Men’s Swimming | Martin N. Berg |
| 1998 | Football | Chad Kessler |
| 2000 | Men’s Tennis | Tom Hand |
| 2000 | Women’s Golf | Lisette Lee |
| 2000 | Gymnastics | Stacey Wegener |
| 2004 | Men’s Tennis | Bryan Fisher |
| 2005 | Gymnastics | Lauren Companioni |
| 2006 | Football | Rudy Niswanger |
| 2007 | Women’s Diving | Hali Saucier |
| 2007 | Men’s Tennis | Kevin Dessauer |
| 2008 | Women’s Basketball | Ashley Thomas |
| 2009 | Women’s Tennis | Staten Spencer |
| 2009 | Volleyball | Lauren Degirolamo |
| 2010 | Football | Orlando Gunn |
| 2010 | Women’s Track and Field | Katleyn Rodrigue |
| 2011 | Men’s Tennis | Sebastian Carlsson |
| 2012 | Men’s Diving | Matt Vieke |
| 2015 | Softball | Dylan Supak |
| 2015 | Gymnastics | Lloimincia Hall |
